PhysicsShortJEE Main and Advanced

Velocity Zero, Acceleration Not

At the top of a vertical throw the ball stops for an instant, so v = 0. Its acceleration is still g, downward: the velocity keeps changing by 10 m/s every second, through the top too.

Free PDF, 4 pages: the idea, a solved example, practice questions with answers, and the worked answer to the Short's quiz. No sign up.

At the top of a vertical throw the ball stops for an instant: \(v = 0\). Its acceleration is still \(g\), downward, as it is all the way up and down. Zero velocity does not mean zero acceleration.

Velocity

How fast, and which way, the ball is moving now.

Up is positive here.

Acceleration

How fast the velocity is changing: by how much each second.

Here \(-10\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-2}}\): the velocity drops by 10 m/s every second.

One throw, second by second

Throw a ball straight up at 20 m/s (\(g = 10\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-2}}\), no air resistance) and read its velocity every second:

A tennis ball at the top of a vertical throw, at t = 2 s, with v = 0 above it and an orange arrow a = -10 m s^-2 pointing down. Beside it a table of t and v: 0 s, 20 m/s; 1 s, 10; 2 s, 0; 3 s, -10; 4 s, -20, with a step of -10 between every two rows, the two steps through the top shaded. Under it: each second -10 m/s, through the top too.

The velocity goes \(20, 10, 0, -10, -20\) m/s. From each second to the next it changes by the same step, \(-10\) m/s. The two steps through the top (from 1 s to 2 s and from 2 s to 3 s) are the same as the others: at 2 s the velocity passes zero without stopping to change. If the acceleration were zero at the top, the velocity would stay zero there and the ball would hang in the air. It falls, so its velocity is still changing. The acceleration is that step per second, \(-10\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-2}}\), at every instant.

The equations (up positive)

\[ {v} = u - gt, \qquad y = ut - \tfrac{1}{2}gt^2, \qquad t_{\text{top}} = \frac{u}{g}, \qquad H = \frac{u^2}{2g}. \]

At 20 m/s: the top comes at 2 s, at a height of 20 m.

The graph says it at once

On a velocity-time graph the motion is one straight line. It crosses zero at the top, but its slope, the acceleration, is \(-10\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-2}}\) at every point, the top included.

Why \(a\) cannot be zero at the top

If \(a\) were zero there, the velocity would stop changing. It is zero at that instant, so it would stay zero, and the ball would hang in the air for ever. It falls back because gravity is still pulling: \(a = g\) downward.

The velocity-time graph of the throw: a straight line from 20 m/s at t = 0 down to -20 m/s at t = 4 s, crossing the time axis at the top, where v = 0. Its slope is -10 m s^-2 everywhere, the top included.

Careful

"At the highest point the net force is zero" is false: the force on the ball is \(mg\) downward the whole time. The same trap appears wherever something stops to turn back: a pendulum at the end of its swing, or a block on a spring at its farthest point, has \(v = 0\) but \(a \ne 0\).

Solved example

A ball is thrown straight up at 30 m/s. Find the time to the top, the greatest height, and the velocity and acceleration at the top. Take \(g = 10\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-2}}\).

Time. \(t = \frac{u}{g} = \frac{30}{10} = 3\) s. Height. \(H = \frac{u^2}{2g} = \frac{900}{20} = 45\) m.

At the top. \(v = 0\), and \(a = 10\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-2}}\) downward.

3 s, 45 m; \(v = 0\), \(a = g\) downward

Key formulas

\[ \begin{aligned}v &= u - gt & y &= ut - \tfrac{1}{2}gt^2 & v^2 &= u^2 - 2gy\\[3pt] t_{\text{top}} &= \frac{u}{g} & H &= \frac{u^2}{2g} & a &= -g\ \text{at every instant}\end{aligned} \]

Practice set

Easy to hard. Take \(g = 10\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-2}}\) and no air resistance. Try each one before you open its answer.

  1. Quiz from the Short. At the top of the throw, the net force on the ball (mass \(m\)) is:
    (A) \(0\) (B) \(mg\), downward (C) \(mg\), upward.

    Show answer

    (B) \(mg\), downward. At the top \(v = 0\), but \(a = g\) downward, as at every instant of the flight. So the net force is \(F = ma = mg\), downward. It is not zero: if it were, the ball would stay at the top.

  2. A ball is thrown up at 15 m/s. Find the time to the top and the greatest height.

    Show answer

    1.5 s, 11.25 m. \(t = \frac{15}{10}\), \(H = \frac{225}{20}\).

  3. One second after the top, what are the ball's velocity and acceleration?

    Show answer

    10 m/s downward; \(10\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-2}}\) downward. The velocity has changed by \(-10\) m/s from zero; the acceleration never changes.

  4. A ball is thrown up at 20 m/s. Where is it at \(t = 3\) s, and how fast is it moving?

    Show answer

    15 m up, moving 10 m/s downward. \(y = 20 \times 3 - 5 \times 9 = 15\) m; \(v = 20 - 30 = -10\) m/s.

  5. A swinging pendulum stops for an instant at its highest point. Is its acceleration there zero?

    Show answer

    No, it is not zero. At the highest point \(v = 0\), but gravity still pulls the bob back along its path: the acceleration is \(g \sin \theta_0\) along the arc, where \(\theta_0\) is the angle from the vertical. That is why it swings back.

  6. A ball is thrown up at 25 m/s. How long is it in the air before it returns to the hand?

    Show answer

    5 s. Up for \(\frac{u}{g} = 2.5\) s, and the same time down.

Get the next Short

Subscribe on YouTube and tap the bell. Every Short comes with free notes on this site.

Subscribe on YouTube

Keep these notes

The same notes as a printable PDF, with the practice set and answers.

All Shorts with notes

Link copied